Re: [討論] 柏舉之戰與後續

作者: MrTaxes (得粥加湯)   2025-05-31 18:40:33
※ 引述《plamc (普蘭可)》之銘言:
: ※ 引述《MrTaxes (謝謝提醒)》之銘言:
: : 何以獨獨孫子兵法能夠廣為流傳千年,並且還被翻譯成各國語言成為各國軍校教科書?
: 呃,除非你的「各國」是指台灣國、香港國跟中國,軍校的確必教孫子兵法
: 不然其他軍校當指定教科書這回事,你跟我說說是哪國的哪家軍校課本?
美國西點軍校:
The Art of War, attributed to Sun Tzu, is studied at the United States
Military Academy (West Point) in the course Military Strategy (470). It's
also on the US Marine Corps Professional Reading Program. The book's
principles are also used at other military academies, like the Royal Military
Academy Sandhurst.
美國維吉尼亞軍校:
Virginia Military Institute (VMI) includes the study of Sun Tzu's "Art of
War" in its courses, particularly in areas related to military and strategic
studies. The school uses Sun Tzu's work to analyze military strategies,
including those employed by China, and to examine how the U.S. can learn from
his principles to improve its national security.
英國桑德赫斯特皇家軍事學院:
The British military has a long-standing appreciation for Sun Tzu's The Art
of War. The text is a subject of study for officers at the Royal Military
Academy, Sandhurst and is used as instructional material at other military
institutions like the US Military Academy (West Point) and the US Marine
Corps.
至於書籍的版本呢,請自行上亞馬遜搜尋,外文版本多不勝數。
普蘭可大大,沒有對你不敬的意思。但是...
聽說你服役期間是當醫官,負責幫阿兵哥開藥,頂多再督導一下伙房的衛生管理。
然後聽說醫官考試還不用考孫子兵法?不清楚。 反正戰鬥兵科是必考的啦。
雖然小弟不才,只是義務役砲兵預官,但也帶過兵、射過砲,兼情報單位小幕僚。
所以對於孫子兵法的評價、理解或體悟,的確可能因人而異。大概是這樣。
作者: plamc (普蘭可)   2025-05-31 18:46:00
就是我上篇說的有相關選修課程而已,跟列必修教科書可不同國軍則當然是教考孫子兵法的,香港跟中國的軍校也是,如前
作者: peterlee97 (瑋美絕倫迷)   2025-06-01 01:22:00
跟標題越來越遠了..
作者: ciike4 (饃钕嗤棨澌)   2025-06-01 03:25:00
現代的孫子兵法有沒有部分是孫子回齊國後增加的篇章? 是後人或弟子整理的話很有可能加進去吧?
作者: kkStBvasut (奧匈帝國皇家鐵道)   2025-06-01 07:04:00
@plamc: 香港沒有軍校。
作者: gekorader (基果雷德)   2025-06-01 12:13:00
以這種沒有被詳加記錄追蹤內容增刪的著作而言,當然有可能無法確定流傳下來的是該書的哪一版,即便如太史公書自己加了幾次相關註解,也不免疫散軼、考據對不上等問題嘛
作者: IBIZA (溫一壺月光作酒)   2025-06-02 02:19:00
plamc基本上講話很多是靠空想 你所謂孫子兵法有相關選修課程的依據是甚麼?

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com