[疑問] HRE為何可以長存?

作者: ung0952q (乂煞氣a禿頭乂)   2016-11-13 16:55:12
*更新:
剛剛在書上有看到大概有三個原因可是看不太懂,望各位大大開示:
1、The answer is complicated, with one reason being the development of the com
munity of surrounding nations that needed a weak, internally fragment center i
n which they could adjust the shifting balance of their own interests and figh
t their wars.
(這裡實在看不懂,他們需要一個很弱的中心讓他們能夠……?)
2、Another reason was the emperor’s very weakness, which tended to make him a
n effective peacemaker and a sovereign who ruled through fixed law instead of
a despot.
(為何皇帝很弱,所以變成一個和平主義者?)
3、A further reason for the surprising longevity of the Holy Roman Empire was
the principle of the elective kingship. The higher rank of the aristocracy par
ticipated in the institutions and were disposed to support and cooperate with
the sovereign they chose. Every vote they cast in a royal election was a renew
ed vote for the continuation of the empire, and thus it was precisely the prin
ce elector who came to serve as guarantors of its cohesion and permanence.
(這邊好像比較能夠理解,大概是自己選的皇帝,自己挺?)
-
小妹不才,最近正在念德意志地區的歷史,不過有點疑問,希望各位大大解惑。
日耳曼在政治上十分分裂,照理說紛爭那麼多,內憂外患的,神聖羅馬帝國到後來也是德
意志自己在玩的,那為什麼他可以存在到19世紀才消失呢?
才疏學淺,有哪裡不正確的地方,懇請各位指教。
作者: ilha   2016-11-13 17:01:00
中程理論
作者: jason222333 (發呆)   2016-11-13 17:06:00
因為天主教與教宗要有靠山
作者: leptoneta (台湾高山族自治区书记)   2016-11-13 18:33:00
奧地利:因為沒人能完全打爆我 直到拿破崙出現
作者: dasfriedrich (天行健)   2016-11-13 20:22:00
也有一開始當教宗靠山,後來卻直接給教宗來個土石流的狀況。
作者: RollingWave (Lost in the Dark)   2016-11-13 21:09:00
跟天皇為何不會被廢掉有點類似當然HRE皇帝沒到天皇那麼弱
作者: reallurker (一個好人)   2016-11-13 23:55:00
因為沒人能獨大 歐陸權力平衡的玩法 加上歷史淵源皇帝 選帝侯 各地國王 大領主 小領主 保持政治經濟的妥協與平衡
作者: dasfriedrich (天行健)   2016-11-14 05:36:00
就是因為權力平衡,所以馬丁路德才能到處躲爽爽,沒被抓去燒了......
作者: yuriaki (百合秋)   2016-11-14 09:21:00
因為HRE皇帝只是一個頭銜 不是一個特定勢力 正如埃及改朝換代幾千年都還有個法老王HRE皇帝一千年沒什麼特別的至於你讀到的理由一 是中歐領主面對外地威脅需要一個軍事互助同盟就是HRE 理由二 由於以上理由各領主只希望盟主維護基本秩序 不要介入各地內政所以HRE皇帝難以強勢 多只能是peacemaker性質的盟主

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com