[新聞] Did Asus bamboozle the FCC?

作者: rurugia (佛撞牆)   2013-11-16 17:28:14
1.原文連結:
http://0rz.tw/Hv6CZ
2.內容:
Asus Mum as Netgear Sues Company for Falsifying Wi-Fi Router Test Results to
the FCC
Posted 08/15/2013 at 2:46pm | by Paul Lilly
Did Asus bamboozle the FCC?
Netgear is making some pretty serious accusations against rival Asus in
regards to two of the company's wireless routers, the RT-N65U and RT-AC66U.
According to a complaint filed with the FCC and subsequent lawsuit, Netgear
says the aforementioned routers that sit on store shelves and are available
to purchase online emit higher wireless signals than what the FCC allows.
Netgear further alleges that Asus conspired with QuieTek Corporation, an
independent testing laboratory, to submit false test results to the FCC to
ensure certification as part of a grand plan to eliminate Asus' competitors
from the wireless market.
We reached out to Asus for comment but have not heard back. That means we
only have Netgear's side of the story, and there's plenty to tell. Netgear
claims it voiced its concerns to Asus earlier in the year but didn't like the
response it got, especially after its own tests revealed that Asus' routers
failed a number of tests required for FCC certification.
If Netgear's allegations are true, it means the routers in question could
interfere with other electronic devices and potentially pose a safety hazard.
The FCC won't take kindly to that, nor would it be happy that it was duped,
if that's in fact the outcome. On the other hand, if the FCC finds that Asus
is in the clear, Netgear could be hit with a countersuit.
Asus RT-AC66U Back
Since all this went down, Asus issued a new set of firmware that lowers
output levels and deleted all previous versions from their website. Netgear
believes Asus is trying to cover its tracks. David Henry, Vice President of
Product Management for Netgear's Retail Business Unit, provided the following
statement to Maximum PC:
After Netgear filed its formal complaint and lawsuit against Asus in July
2013, the company released a new firmware update for both routers mentioned
in the lawsuit. Typically, when Asus releases updated firmware they continue
to provide access to previous versions, but Asus has deleted all of its old
firmware from their website for each product. One month ago they had seven
firmware versions available for each product and today only one (RT-N65U) or
two (RT-AC66U) is available. People can draw their own conclusions about what
that means, but we find it very suspicious that they would do that.
Netgear's lawsuit against Asus accuses the company of all kinds of
tomfoolery, including false advertising, unfair competition, violating the
Sherman Act, and other monkey business translated into legal speak.
3.心得/評論(必需填寫):
2013/08/17 OpTicaL留言:
Netgear should spend more time fixing their own shietty routers than waste
time testing other people's routers. ASUS releases new firmware updates
consistently while Netgear's garbage receives no updates after it's released.
2013/08/17 Meta23留言:
Does anyone know what's firmware version that I should go look for for the
300% boost ?
2013/08/16 axiomatic留言:
Never upgrade the FW on my RT-AC66U ever again to keep the 200mw option.
Thanks Netgear... you'll get skipped next time I look at routers.
2013/08/16 slim818留言:
I've had the asus rt-ac66u since December and I love it. I got it because the
Uverse gateway sucks and I needed an alternative to route my network. It's
the best router I've ever had.
2013/08/16 Hey.That_Dude留言:
Hey Netgear,
Since you have so much time to test out your competition's routers, why don't
you work on better coding your routers? How about fixing the MAJOR and
OBVIOUS security holes in almost all of your routers? How about fixing
features that you said you'd provide but break your router? How about making
a router that I would be proud to buy?
Sincerely,
That_Dude
P.S. To all companies, Let's pick up the gambit and start offering LTS on
some of your products.
大意是說:
1.華碩這款產品很好 Netgear最好多花點時間改進自己產品 而非花注心力在無謂訴訟上
(米國動不動訴諸法律的行為 其實是很司空見慣的)
2.華碩該產品效率原本就很好 但因為訴頌而更新版本 可是更新版本會讓效率變差
(米國人知道不要更新該產品 就能享受原有高效服務)
(就算不小心更新 但只要再刷回原版本即可)
3.所以網路對Netgear罵聲連連 而Netgear在華碩發佈更新版本後就收聲了
(眾怒難犯)
4.這是在7-8月間的事 並未禁售 只是發佈更新版本 但 大家不下載更新版就好了XD
(因為並沒禁售 自然對營收和獲利並未產生影響)
(華碩目前主力產品在平板.非常規筆電 Q3 EPS 6.65)
這應該有回答到你的問題了吧~
作者: zxcvb1234522 (滑仔)   2012-01-16 19:33:00
華碩心虛了,NETGEAR暗爽中
作者: zxcvb1234522 (滑仔)   2012-01-17 00:09:00
華碩自知理虧才會upgrade符合FCC規範的韌體,華碩自
作者: zxcvb1234522 (滑仔)   2012-01-17 00:19:00
廢武功,以後應該不敢在韌體上動手腳

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com