Re: [SC. ] og11 sc99 just as x, so y.

作者: A2GMAT (A兔GMAT)   2014-10-21 16:27:45
※ 引述《nbk1943 (professor YA)》之銘言:
: OG11版黄皮
: 99. Just as reading Samuel Pepys's diary gives a student a sense of the
: seventeenth century - of its texture and psyche - so Jane Freed's guileless
: child-narrator takes the operagoer inside turn-of-the- century Vienna.
: (A) so Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer
: (B) so listening to Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer
: (C) so the guileless child narrator of Jane Freed takes the operagoer
: (D) listening to Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer
: (E) Jane Freed’s guileless child narrator takes the operagoer to her opera
: 答案B
: 解釋
: This sentence is based on the comparative construction just as x, so y, x and
: y must be grammatically parallel elements. The underlined portion of the
: sentence makes up most of the y element, which must be revised to make it
: parallel to the x clement. The first part of the comparison is about reading
: a diary, and the second part is about listening to a narrator.
: Reading Samuel Pepys’s diary gives a student ... is parallel to listening to
: Jane Freed’s ... narrator takes the operagoer
: 疑問
: just as x, so y. 逗號在題目裡不見了,所以會被誤導去選D;
: just as x, y. 這樣文法上有錯嗎?
應該是這樣說, 在標準英文中, 表達類比擺在主要子句句首通常有兩種方式
1. AS S+V+O, S+V+O
2. Just as S+V+O, so S+V+O
所以在句首的just as在idiom上都是要配so, 如果單純用just as子句當答案時
通常會在句中或句尾的結構, 舉例如下:
34. (26262-!-item-!-188;#058&003094)
Besides adding complementary flavors to many foods, hot sauces
stimulate the release of endorphins in the brain, just as exercise
does, and these have a pain-relieving effect like morphine's.
作者: nbk1943 (professor YA)   2014-10-25 23:45:00
謝謝你點出正確用法!!

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com