[文法] 請問 when過去式+would have 用法是?

作者: kopuck (派翠克星星)   2021-06-14 09:34:25
大家好,最近聽到一個句子是
When I was a kid, baling a field of hay that big would have taken a really
long time and it would have all been done with manual labor.
他是提到現在收割打包很快,但以前要花很多時間,而且要全靠人工
想請問大家,他後面那邊
(1)接would have pp 跟 接簡單過去式 聽起來的感覺差在哪呢
(2)後面用簡單過去式也可以嗎?
謝謝
作者: PPmYeah (寂寞雪山隧道)   2021-06-14 10:16:00
謂語層次上的理解是,用過去簡單式的著重點在於描繪「事實性」,而這邊的寫法則強調「狀態的持續、慣常性、畫面感」
作者: kopuck (派翠克星星)   2021-06-14 15:07:00
喔喔喔 了解 謝謝您!!!

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com