即然有人質疑CYP的權重過時了
那就把CYP跟開獎結果拿出來比一比就好啦
簡單列一下近五年數據
Rk Player CYP RK Player Vote Pts
2013 AL
1 Max Scherzer 202.1 1 Max Scherzer 203
2 Joe Nathan 171.5 2 Yu Darvish 93
3 Bartolo Colon 170.5 3 Hisashi Iwakuma 73
4 Mariano Rivera 167.1 4 Anibal Sanchez 46
5 Greg Holland 164.3 5 Chris Sale 44
2013 NL
1 Clayton Kershaw 194.4 1 Clayton Kershaw 207
2 Craig Kimbrel 191.4 2 Adam Wainwright 86
3 Adam Wainwright 183.5 3 Jose Fernandez 62
4 Zack Greinke 154 4 Matt Harvey 39
5 J. Zimmermann 152.9 4 Craig Kimbrel 39
2012 AL
1 David Price 185.3 1 David Price 153
2 J. Verlander 181.3 2 J. Verlander 149
3 Fernando Rodney 170.8 3 Jered Weaver 70
4 Jered Weaver 169.7 4 Felix Hernandez 41
5 Jim Johnson 160.1 5 Fernando Rodney 38
2012 NL
1 R.A. Dickey 189 1 R.A. Dickey 209
2 Gio Gonzalez 187 2 Clayton Kershaw 96
3 Johnny Cueto 175.7 3 Gio Gonzalez 93
4 Matt Cain 169.9 4 Johnny Cueto 75
5 Aroldis Chapman 165 5 Craig Kimbrel 41
2011 AL
1 J. Verlander 241.3 1 J. Verlander 196
2 CC Sabathia 183 2 Jered Weaver 97
3 Jered Weaver 178.4 3 James Shields 66
4 Jose Valverde 166.4 4 CC Sabathia 63
5 C.J. Wilson 163.2 5 Jose Valverde 28
2011 NL
1 Clayton Kershaw 209.3 1 Clayton Kershaw 207
2 Roy Halladay 202.2 2 Roy Halladay 133
3 Ian Kennedy 199.8 3 Cliff Lee 90
4 Cliff Lee 191.1 4 Ian Kennedy 76
5 Craig Kimbrel 168.4 5 Cole Hamels 17
2010 AL
1 David Price 183.6 1 Felix Hernandez 167
2 CC Sabathia 176.5 2 David Price 111
3 Rafael Soriano 165.9 3 CC Sabathia 102
4 Jon Lester 155.3 4 Jon Lester 33
5 Neftali Feliz 153.4 5 Jered Weaver 24
7 Felix Hernandez 150
2010 NL
1 Roy Halladay 211.5 1 Roy Halladay 224
2 Adam Wainwright 183.7 2 Adam Wainwright 122
3 Heath Bell 182.6 3 Ubaldo Jimenez 90
4 Brian Wilson 178.2 4 Tim Hudson 39
5 Ubaldo Jimenez 170 5 Josh Johnson 34
如果只看CY得主 CYP好像還是很準
除了10年的King意外竄出(或是不意外?)
不過再看看2~5名 怎麼就變亂槍打鳥呢？！
是不是調整某些權重可以更準一些 有請板上的神人們來算算看了